So-Called Dollar Discussions
UNLISTED SO-CALLED DOLLAR?
Quote from victorio1sw on February 23, 2015, 12:32 pmI am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 Nice token no hole and looks to be above average condition. Possibly even AU. I would say you should be able to realize between $185- $215were you to put it up for sale. If you do let me know on this site as I would watch it to see how close I was. There is a new book out in 2008 but it is not listed in it either. I am not aware of this token being listed any where. The new book for those listed does scrap the old rarity rating system you are complaining about and replace it with the R-1 to R-10 system. If you have other questions don't hesitate to ask since someone on this site will undoubtedly know the answer. Bill G CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE edited by victorio1sw on 2/23/2015
I am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 Nice token no hole and looks to be above average condition. Possibly even AU. I would say you should be able to realize between $185- $215were you to put it up for sale. If you do let me know on this site as I would watch it to see how close I was. There is a new book out in 2008 but it is not listed in it either. I am not aware of this token being listed any where. The new book for those listed does scrap the old rarity rating system you are complaining about and replace it with the R-1 to R-10 system. If you have other questions don't hesitate to ask since someone on this site will undoubtedly know the answer. Bill G CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE edited by victorio1sw on 2/23/2015
Quote from billycgribble on February 23, 2015, 1:26 pmI have seen several HK-574 pieces over the years, but in the recent 2015 Stacks auction, I saw a white metal version (HK-574a) -- image attached. I was not aware this piece came in white metal. Congrats to the new owner ($620 later...) I was interested in this piece but too rich for me... edited by rjesinger on 2/14/2015
I have seen several HK-574 pieces over the years, but in the recent 2015 Stacks auction, I saw a white metal version (HK-574a) -- image attached. I was not aware this piece came in white metal. Congrats to the new owner ($620 later...) I was interested in this piece but too rich for me... edited by rjesinger on 2/14/2015
Quote from victorio1sw on February 23, 2015, 1:44 pmI am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE edited by victorio1sw on 2/23/2015
I am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE edited by victorio1sw on 2/23/2015
Quote from billycgribble on February 23, 2015, 5:23 pmI am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE
To somebody like myself who collects the unlisted socalleds it would have a value of between $85 and $215 depending upon the condition. It could not have corrosion, be bent, or dented or badly cut or scratched. It is best also if it doesn't have a hole drilled in it. Do you have the resources to post a picture? Most of us would like to see it. It sounds like a historical interesting token.
I am have questions about the following as described. It is Alum-Rd-37 mm. In VF-XF condition, what is it worth? This piece didn't seem to be listed in the H&K book, published in 1963. If there ever is another book, I hope that rarity ranges like 1 to 50 and 51 to 250 are never used again, as these are way too wide to be a real rarity scale. Jim HALL VS FITZSIMMONS / (FIGHTERS IN BOXING RING) / $40,000 / MARCH 8TH 1893 CRESCENTCITY ALTHLETIC CLUB / (PICTURE OF BUILDING) / AMPHITHEATRE
To somebody like myself who collects the unlisted socalleds it would have a value of between $85 and $215 depending upon the condition. It could not have corrosion, be bent, or dented or badly cut or scratched. It is best also if it doesn't have a hole drilled in it. Do you have the resources to post a picture? Most of us would like to see it. It sounds like a historical interesting token.